• Stone Cold Magic & Born in Fire

    The first book in Jayne Faith’s Ella Grey series starts off pretty good, almost like a combination of Greywalker and Kate Daniels. Sadly, it spontaneously combusts about halfway through when the protagonist starts to think of herself as an infiltration expert despite having little magic power and no related skills. Wasn’t a huge fan of her self-destructive obsessions with both her missing brother and the random girl she just met either.

    K.F. Breene’s Born in Fire, by contrast, starts out terrible. So terrible I seriously considered dropping it a mere 3 pages in. But I’ve forced myself through worse and pressed on to be rewarded by… a few surprisingly amusing interactions and an uncommon approach to depicting vampires. So despite the near-constant stream of cringe pouring out the protagonist I didn’t end up hating it. Well, at least not until the final chapter which gets real weird in a number of ways.

    Needless to say, I highly doubt I’ll be following either of these series any further.


  • Over the Woodward Wall & CAST IN CONFLICT

    I’m unsure why Over the Woodward Wall, written under the alias A. Deborah Baker, is not a part of Seanan McGuire‘s Wayward Children series. In all ways that matter it’s pretty much identical to those books… so why did she invent a new alias just for this? To trick people who hated that series into thinking it would be more like Middlegame instead?

    Whatever the reason, I’d suggest avoiding it unless you love Wayward Children and/or enjoy paying $12 for less than 200 pages of story.

    Michelle Sagara‘s 16th Elantra novel goes in an unexpected direction from where Cast in Wisdom left off. I had thought it would focus on the protagonist learning to read her marks, but it instead centers on semi-completing Bellusdeo’s character arc and reducing the number of directionless Cohort members laying about. Though to be fair it also introduces a new character who looks like they’ll help quite a bit in the ‘deciphering marks’ department.

    So it’s… more of the same I suppose? Which, at least as far as I’m concerned, is a good thing.


  • CLASSROOM of the ELITE #4-5

    I made two mistakes when deciding to read this series. The first was forgetting about all the people who said the Anime version made significant changes to the source material, while the second was accidentally buying the 5th book before the 4th.

    That fourth book picks up shortly after the students leave the deserted island, includes the two brief Ayanokoji/Sakura and Ayanokoji/Kushida interactions shown in the last episode of the Anime, and features a test where the various classes are split into cross-class groups and have to decide whether to work together or betray one another. In terms of event setup and development the Anime is pretty similar… the difference instead is entirely contained to the protagonist; neither his personality nor goals match up.

    The Anime protagonist and the LN protagonist are effectively two different people (as divergent as Akagi and Ainz), which completely changes how otherwise similar event developments come across. To put it bluntly: The LN protagonist is utter trash. And since the best part of the Anime was the protagonist….

    The 5th book, which I never would have bought had I already read the 4th, is slightly better thanks to Ayanokoji acting a bit more like his Anime counterpart. Unfortunately, the event development is completely centered on a school sports festival. A standard, no twists, generic school life series sports festival (populated by characters with garbage personalities). It’s incredibly aggravating.

    So yeah, I can’t really recommend these books to anyone. If you want to check them out anyway though, I’d suggest starting with the 1st book in the series even if you’ve already seen the Anime. The protagonist is so different they may as well be alternative versions of one another.


  • Blood Heir & So I’m a Spider, So What? #12

    I actually read Ilona AndrewsBlood Heir way back at the end of May and just never found a good time to bring it up (since I like to have at least two books to talk about before making a post).

    It’s… okay I guess? It picks up from where the Kate Daniels series left off following a pretty large timeskip with Julie as the new protagonist. Events are what you’d come to expect from the franchise, walking back some of the more ludicrous developments of Magic Triumphs, but the romantic developments can’t help feeling like yet another replay of the Curran/Kate relationship.

    The 12th Kumodesuga novel meanwhile answers the question brought to mind by the 11th. Why did that novel focus almost entirely on Julius? Because this one covers the events surrounding his death in greater detail… not that greater detail was needed. Nor was it necessary to devote 2 chapters or so to the two least interesting people in his party.

    Meaning that overall this 12th entry is highly disappointing. Not quite so much as the 11th, but it’s definitely the second worst book in the series I’ve read so far and probably best off skipped entirely (along with its predecessor) on any re-reads.


  • That Time I Got Reincarnated as a SLIME #6-11

    Despite there being an Anime adaptation of this franchise currently airing, it seemed like a good idea to check out the light novel version while waiting for that to finish. Both because I was impatient and because the Anime is based on the manga version (the web novel, light novel, and manga versions each have their own quirks).

    Transferring over from the end of the Anime‘s 36th episode into the 6th and 7th novels, event-wise at least, is a fairly smooth experience. The main things of note are a difference in translation sensibilities (‘magic-born’ instead of ‘majin’ for instance), a much greater focus on RPG-like elements, and some minor character differences (e.g. Raphael being male, Rimuru’s personality trending more toward smarmy than carefree).

    The 8th & 9th books on the other hand stand out both for being a heavily food-centric two-parter and for introducing the series’ worst concept so far: Tempest’s Labyrinth. Just unimaginably stupid; this isn’t Danmachi. And, worst of all, Book 10 devotes its first hundred pages or so to more completely extraneous Labyrinth bullshit. I sincerely hope that the Anime completely cuts out everything related (if it ever gets that far).

    As for the 11th novel, there’s thankfully not really much to complain about here aside from the stage having being set for potential harem shenanigans later.

    Ultimately when all is said and done, while the LN version isn’t objectively bad, it’s notably worse than the Anime version to the point that I would strongly suggest sticking to that unless you really like the franchise or don’t mind reading something that ends up intermittently annoying.


  • ARIFURETA: FROM COMMONPLACE TO WORLD’S STRONGEST #5-11

    Although this franchise is getting a second Anime adaptation relatively soon, I decided to switch over to the novels since the (lack of) quality on display in the earlier adaptation makes it doubtful any continuation will end up any good.

    Happily, it seems the author is not one to pointlessly drag out their stories or cut corners. Less happily, it turns out that the content of the source material is pretty much the same as the content of the Anime. Meaning it’s a fairly stereotypical, if slightly more explicit, action-focused harem series with its one saving grace being not having an oblivious/indecisive protagonist. The Anime did leave out a number of things though, so I’m morbidly curious what the second season is going to do about Lily’s existence and the beastman city.

    Comparisons aside the story advances at a pretty brisk clip until you reach the end, where there’s a pair of two-parters. The 9th and 10th books cover the clearing of the last labyrinth while doubling as something of a character study, while the 11th and (eventual) 12th are the main plotline’s action-heavy climax.

    To be frank, I do not like the 11th book at all. Though the series as a whole has never given a shit about keeping consistent power levels, the constant stream of insanity present here goes well above and beyond what could be considered acceptable. It has no believability whatsoever, which robs what should be dramatic scenes of all tension. What the 6th novel pulled off this one unequivocally fails at.

    Which means I have little hope the 12th (and presumably final) book will end the series well.


  • The Irregular at Magic High School #12-16

    The transition from the end of Raihousha-hen to Book 12 of the source material is unfortunately not particularly seamless.

    There’s some notable overlap between events, namely Minami’s and the Saegusa and Yotsuba twins’ introductions. The skyscraper opening ceremony there meanwhile is actually a near-total alteration of a welcome-home party in the book. An understandable change, seeing as how the original version introduced a bunch of new characters (some of whom are never seen again) and they probably wanted to end the series with a bang.

    What really sticks out though is the density of the text, which shouldn’t have been a surprise considering how wordy the Anime series is. It takes some time to get used to the conversational style, which frequently skips between similarly named characters and occasionally has a rather odd syntax. I wonder if they used multiple editors? When/if you acclimate yourself to the oddities though the general experience is not unlike watching the show, featuring a similar mix of dialog, action, and comedy.

    At least for the 12th through 15th books.

    The 16th however, which (perhaps not incidentally) is the shortest of this bunch, throws a couple pretty severe curve balls which seem completely out of character. Frankly, the way the page count had been steadily decreasing since the 12th book already had me on edge… but then to go and devote what little space they had to such highly questionable developments on top of that has me feeling that there’s no need to continue following the franchise.


  • So I’m a Spider, So What? #6-11

    Despite heavy misgivings, as I have a mixed history regarding young adult novels (and LNs are simply the Japanese equivalent of such), I decided to pick this series up at the point the related Anime ended.

    To my great surprise the transition from episode 24 over there to book 6 over here ended up nearly seamless. The only notable inconsistency is that the protagonist has more parallel minds, a minor issue which ends up resolved anyway by the time the 7th book starts. That 7th book however is a problem. While on paper it sort of works, if it were to be animated it would provoke reactions similar to ones War of the Underworld‘s ending got.

    For the most part this isn’t an issue because nothing important to the main plotline occurs for like 90% of the novel… but that last 10% covers the protagonist getting her human body. An event that can’t really happen without all the otherwise unrelated lead-up. So a hypothetical Anime continuation would have to shoot itself in the foot animating it faithfully, or come up with an Anime-original method for her evolution. It’s a no-win situation.

    The next three books return to the style of the 6th and are solidly entertaining. The 11th however….

    This book is another problem child, but notably more-so than the 7th: 95% of its content is focused on Julius. You remember Julius right? Shun’s idolized older brother who died. That’s right, nearly an entire book given to a character that lost all relevance something like six books back. What was the purpose of this? The only thing that comes to mind is that it’s meant to foreshadow some sort of development with the Hero’s Sword… but that was just one scene. You didn’t need to devote the whole damn thing to a dead character.

    The remaining content is some brief Sophia interludes in which she sounds exactly like the protagonist (who sounds exactly like the author). Being generous this curious personality shift could be attributed to the Envy skill… but considering the book is focused on Julius of all people I suspect the actual reason is that the author simply got lazy/lost sight of her character.

    Regardless, while there were some hiccups, overall I’d have to call this experiment a success. I’m definitely looking forward to the 12th book (the translated version of which will be released later this month) and in the meantime may check out some other Anime-related series that are unlikely to get an animated continuation any time soon.


  • FINAL FANTASY XIV – 3rd Char Conclusion

    Just maxed the last class on my 3rd character, meaning that combined with the previous two I’ve now maxed out all classes in the game.

    Dragoon is an annoying class because you have to constantly switch between two attack lines (if you want to keep your damage buff up) while simultaneously keeping track of your positioning. And it certainly doesn’t help that its questgiver is located out in the middle of nowhere. It has quite a few instant attacks however and ends up fairly decent at evasion once you get the hang of them. The party buffing abilities are a nice bonus.

    Samurai gives you a bit more leeway with your buffs (they last longer), but forces you to keep track of an expendable resource in addition to adding a 3rd (shorter) attack sequence. That combined with the focus on high skill speed results in a class that’s extremely busy and a real pain to play optimally. The main saving grace here is that there’s no need to worry about positioning. One other thing to note is that, unlike all other classes, its level 60 quest requires an ilevel of 200+ to beat.

    Paladin turned out to be a hybrid Tank/Healer; in addition to the standard suite of tanking abilities it also gets a strong single-target heal and some attack magic. The shield starts showing its worth once you get Sheltron at 35 and yeah this is definitely the class with the most survivability. It’s just generally good all around.

    Warrior is sort of odd. It swaps out some of Paladin’s defense for more offense, but that offense is quite limited and not really worth the trade unless you’re doing solo duties/quests. Personally I only ended up using it for PvP.

    Dark Knight has been my go-to tanking class and is quite a bit of fun. It’s magic themed, meaning it has some defensive abilities that only work against magic attacks (which I often forget to use) and uses MP to provide both more offense and more defense. The MP shield, Blackest Night, is fantastic and can even be used to defend the main tank if you happen to be off-tanking. Probably the busiest of the tanking classes though with all the instants and resources you have to keep track off.

    Finally we come to Gunbreaker, which is a hybrid Tank/DPS with a bit of Healer thrown in for some reason. The healing abilities aren’t anything to write home about (beyond that they’re instant), but its DPS-like attack combo makes it one of the more aggressive tanking options available thanks to having a relatively short cooldown time.

    Ultimately, tanking is quite a bit of fun and vastly preferable to playing melee DPS or (gods forbid) Healer. All you really have to worry about is keeping the boss faced away from the party (Hansel/Gretel fight excepted) and using defensive abilities if/when the boss uses a tankbuster attack. Most mechanics don’t even target you, and those that do will often barely hurt even if you mess them up. It’s great.

    One thing I have noticed however is that tanks on the Aether data center in general seem to absolutely hate having their tank stance on (presumably because it used to lower stats?). Meaning if you aren’t tanking there be prepared to get swarmed by adds during raids and have your healers blitzed if/when the MT dies.


  • FINAL FANTASY XIV – Tanking: First Impressions

    After more or less hitting the endgame wall with my first two characters I went and created the third and presumably final one a couple days ago (please excuse the lack of proper glamour; my funds are currently being funneled into leveling Armorer and I have none to spare on dye).

    This one is meant to cover the various tanking classes along with Dragoon & Samurai, and my first impressions regarding the tank role are quite favorable.

    I’m not sure why it’s not a more popular role considering it can both deal damage and survive situations that would shred your average DPS. Sure you rely upon the Healer in order to survive most Boss fights or larger pulls… but so does DPS (post-60 Red Mage being the occasional exception).

    Though I will grant that my initial experience with Gladiator has been underwhelming. The damage is pretty anemic compared to Marauder (let alone DPS) and the shield doesn’t seem to make much of a difference survivability-wise. I’ve been equally unimpressed with Lancer so far, seeing that as of level 30 it completely lacks any AOE attack and has the same attack range as other melee classes. What’s the deal with that? Enemy lancers have an early line-attack called Heartstopper… why don’t players?

    So Marauder has been my go-to class so far, featuring as it does both high defense and high damage.

    Going back to my second character for a bit, in the end I think I like it more than my
    ‘main’. While it lacks the self-sufficiently of RDM, Dancer is extremely mobile and easy to play. I’ve even come around a bit on Monk. Sure it can only hit things at point-blank range, but it hits things quite hard.

    I think my least favorite class at this point may be Machinist. It just… doesn’t really work. Something feels missing or out of place or something. It’s just uncomfortable to play.

    We’ll have to see how Paladin/Warrior/Dragoon, Samurai, Dark Knight, and Gunbreaker stack up down the road.

    Oh yeah, and now having experienced all 3 starting scenarios I can confidently say that Ul’Dah‘s is by far the most well integrated with the overall plotline (while Limsa‘s is the most disconnected). So start a new character in that city if at all possible.