Skip to content
Skip to SEARCH-2
Skip to PAGES-3
Skip to CATEGORIES-2
Skip to ARCHIVES-2
Skip to META-2
Skip to TEXT-3
Various thoughts on a variety of topics.

Various Thoughts

Various thoughts on a variety of topics.

← Older posts
  • Tag Archives Seanan McGuire
  • SYMBIONT & OVERGROWTH

    Posted on May 6, 2025 12:32 pm by Offkorn Comment

    Picking up Symbiont after suddenly realizing one day that I had forgotten about Seanan McGuire‘s Parasitology series, I rather quickly realized why it slipped my mind. There’s just something not quite right about it, something missing… a lack of engagement. It kind of feels more like a set-piece than an actual story.

    I happened to have pre-ordered Overgrowth, an unrelated novel by the same author, at the same time and that turned out much better. It’s basically a mix of elements from both the above series and her Newsflesh one and for the most part works extremely well. The only real stumbling block is the government abduction toward the middle, which fortunately doesn’t last all that long.

    Related posts:

    1. ARE YOU EVEN HUMAN & FEEDBACK Natalie Maher‘s Are You Even Human is a difficult book...
    2. Tempt the Stars, Omens, & Parasite The sixth book in Karen Chance‘s Cassandra Palmer series is...
    3. Sparrow Hill Road & Laughter at the Academy The first of Seanan McGuire’s Ghost Roads novels is a...
    4. Rise: A Newsflesh Collection This is a collection of short stories and novellas which...
    5. Recent Books Normally I do these three at a time… but, well…...

    Powered by YARPP.


    This entry was posted in Book Related and tagged Mira Grant Paranormal Romance Parasitology Science Fiction Seanan McGuire
  • ARE YOU EVEN HUMAN & FEEDBACK

    Posted on March 10, 2025 7:28 am by Offkorn Comment

    Natalie Maher‘s Are You Even Human is a difficult book to categorize. While it certainly starts out as post-apocalyptic survival, it’s also on a character-driven journey to answer the question of the title and shifts into a completely different genre once the military takes center stage. Closer to an agency thriller maybe? There are lots of different directions it could go at this point, so it’ll be interesting to see how things progress.

    Feedback, the fourth novel in Mira Grant/Seanan McGuire‘s Newsflesh series is mostly an outside look at the events of Feed that goes rather off the rails in its second half. That first half is quite good even if some of the events feel like retcons, but the second half just… isn’t. The CDC doesn’t get a focus until Deadline, and so having them hit as hard as they do here just doesn’t gel with previous events. And then that whole raider abduction thing? What even is that?

    So I’m left with pretty mixed feelings on the novel as a whole and can’t really recommend it.

    Related posts:

    1. Tempt the Stars, Omens, & Parasite The sixth book in Karen Chance‘s Cassandra Palmer series is...
    2. Relatively Recent Books Been procrastinating with adding these because it’s a pain. May...
    3. Middlegame, Siren’s Song, & Honors Seanan McGuire‘s Middlegame is a standalone story with no relation...
    4. Recent Books Normally I do these three at a time… but, well…...
    5. Sparrow Hill Road & Laughter at the Academy The first of Seanan McGuire’s Ghost Roads novels is a...

    Powered by YARPP.


    This entry was posted in Book Related and tagged Are You Even Human Mira Grant Natalie Maher Newsflesh Paranormal Romance Romance Science Fiction Seanan McGuire Urban Fantasy
  • BE the SERPENT & Ruby Fever

    Posted on September 4, 2022 6:04 am by Offkorn Comment

    After the previous October Daye entry, things were looking up for the protagonist. So I suppose it shouldn’t be much of a surprise that McGuire’s follow-up is particularly brutal. There is definitely more lost than gained here, and ending on a cliffhanger (which I don’t recall any of the previous novels doing) does it absolutely no favors. Even the short story at the end is pretty downbeat, covering as it does exactly how the sea witch ended up bound.

    The sixth Hidden Legacy novel meanwhile continues the trend of the previous in no longer feeling like Kate Daniels fanfiction. It’s legitimately come into its own at this point… albeit as a fairly standard (if perhaps a bit action-heavy) paranormal romance series. This one marks the end of Catalina’s stint as protagonist, and if the hints at the end are any indication the youngest sister will be the focus of the next book.

    Related posts:

    1. Magic Triumphs, The Brightest Fell, & Night and Silence The long-running plotline regarding Kate’s father is brought to something...
    2. The Unkindest Tide & Archangel’s War Seanan McQuire’s 13th October Daye novel is meant to conclude...
    3. The Witch With No Name, The Great Ordeal, & The Unholy Consult The concluding novel in Kim Harrison‘s Hollows series makes it...
    4. Books; Before and After First the before, which was three books read back in...
    5. WHEN SORROWS COME & That Time I Got Reincarnated as a SLIME #12 Seanan McGuire‘s fifteenth October Daye novel is completely centered on...

    Powered by YARPP.


    This entry was posted in Book Related and tagged Hidden Legacy Ilona Andrews October Daye Paranormal Romance Seanan McGuire Urban Fantasy
  • WHEN SORROWS COME & That Time I Got Reincarnated as a SLIME #12

    Posted on November 11, 2021 3:32 am by Offkorn Comment

    Seanan McGuire‘s fifteenth October Daye novel is completely centered on the protagonist’s wedding. Despite not actually being short, it feels short both due to everything taking place in one location and because the story itself is episodic. If it weren’t for the fact that this event is pretty important to the overall plotline I would’ve said it was merely a transitional novel (similar to the Unkindest Tide).

    The twelfth TenSura novel meanwhile is basically a repeat of Book 6 without any of the action. Also with a 1-year timeskip and an abrupt ending. On the positive side of things they don’t dwell too much on the Labyrinth RPG aspects and it appears as though the next book will have quite a bit of movement with the whole start of the East vs. West war. Then again, there are apparently six more books already published in this series so I can’t rule out additional volumes of nothing but preparation (and if that’s the case for the next entry I’ll probably just drop the series).

    Related posts:

    1. Recent Books Normally I do these three at a time… but, well…...
    2. The Witch With No Name, The Great Ordeal, & The Unholy Consult The concluding novel in Kim Harrison‘s Hollows series makes it...
    3. Hollow Regalia & The Strange Adventure of a Broke MERCENARY #7 The Utsuro naru Regalia series is apparently written by the...
    4. The Hero Laughs #7 & That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime #19 The seventh Nidome no Yuusha novel thankfully keeps the incestuous...
    5. Blood Heir & So I’m a Spider, So What? #12 I actually read Ilona Andrews‘ Blood Heir way back at...

    Powered by YARPP.


    This entry was posted in Book Related and tagged Fantasy FUSE October Daye Paranormal Romance Seanan McGuire TenSura Urban Fantasy Young Adult Novel
  • Over the Woodward Wall & CAST IN CONFLICT

    Posted on July 27, 2021 6:21 am by Offkorn Comment

    I’m unsure why Over the Woodward Wall, written under the alias A. Deborah Baker, is not a part of Seanan McGuire‘s Wayward Children series. In all ways that matter it’s pretty much identical to those books… so why did she invent a new alias just for this? To trick people who hated that series into thinking it would be more like Middlegame instead?

    Whatever the reason, I’d suggest avoiding it unless you love Wayward Children and/or enjoy paying $12 for less than 200 pages of story.

    Michelle Sagara‘s 16th Elantra novel goes in an unexpected direction from where Cast in Wisdom left off. I had thought it would focus on the protagonist learning to read her marks, but it instead centers on semi-completing Bellusdeo’s character arc and reducing the number of directionless Cohort members laying about. Though to be fair it also introduces a new character who looks like they’ll help quite a bit in the ‘deciphering marks’ department.

    So it’s… more of the same I suppose? Which, at least as far as I’m concerned, is a good thing.

    Related posts:

    1. Sparrow Hill Road & Laughter at the Academy The first of Seanan McGuire’s Ghost Roads novels is a...
    2. Cast In Wisdom & A Killing Frost Back in Cast In Oblivion you may remember that the...
    3. Dahlia in Bloom: Crafting a Fresh Start With Magical Tools #1-5 Madougushi Dahlia wa Utsumukanai turned out to be a fairly...
    4. Recent Books Normally I do these three at a time… but, well…...
    5. CAST IN ETERNITY & Solo Leveling #6 Michelle Sagara‘s follow-up to Cast in Conflict decides to greatly...

    Powered by YARPP.


    This entry was posted in Book Related and tagged A. Deborah Baker Chronicles of Elantra Fantasy Michelle Sagara Seanan McGuire The Up-and-Under Young Adult Novel
  • Cast In Wisdom & A Killing Frost

    Posted on September 2, 2020 12:43 am by Offkorn Comment

    Back in Cast In Oblivion you may remember that the protagonist finally decided to learn more about how to use her powers. Well, the 15th book (not including Cast In Moonlight) in Michelle Sagara‘s Chronicles of Elantra series take the necessary step of introducing a new location filled with characters who can advance that goal. It ends up one of the better installments (despite a continued lack of weight to the action scenes) thanks to both not getting bogged down in metaphysics and Kaylin’s continuing maturation as a character; for those saying she never changes you really need to read the first book (Cast In Shadow) again and then realize that less than 2 years have passed since then.

    Seanan McGuire’s A Killing Frost, the 14th October Daye entry, also advances its goal… far more than I thought it would after the meandering prequel. Not only is the titular ‘Search for Simon’ subplot resolved, but one of the series’ major overarching plotlines gets spontaneously resolved as well. Perhaps a bit too spontaneously. Presumably that event will be examined in more detail in the future, put aside here as it was in favor of wrapping up Simon’s arc, and I hope the author can come up with a believable enough justification for it.

    As for the bonus novella included within: It’s a perfectly fine prequel focusing on the Lordens’ relationship with Simon, which adds some useful context to Killing Frost‘s developments.

    Related posts:

    1. Recent Books Normally I do these three at a time… but, well…...
    2. WHEN SORROWS COME & That Time I Got Reincarnated as a SLIME #12 Seanan McGuire‘s fifteenth October Daye novel is completely centered on...
    3. Cast In Oblivion & Guild Hunter #6-11 The fourteenth entry in Michelle Sagara‘s Elantra series resolves the...
    4. Over the Woodward Wall & CAST IN CONFLICT I’m unsure why Over the Woodward Wall, written under the...
    5. Sparrow Hill Road & Laughter at the Academy The first of Seanan McGuire’s Ghost Roads novels is a...

    Powered by YARPP.


    This entry was posted in Book Related and tagged Chronicles of Elantra Fantasy Michelle Sagara October Daye Paranormal Romance Seanan McGuire Urban Fantasy
  • Indexing: Reflections & Wayward Children

    Posted on April 30, 2020 10:50 am by Offkorn Comment

    The second entry in Seanan McGuire’s Indexing series does not appear to have any reason to exist. Oh sure, the foreword says something about people asking “What came next” and that this was the answer… but basically nothing is resolved here, a few additional things are now unresolved, and it ends in pretty much the exact same place the first book did. Just skip it until/unless a third entry is ever written.

    Speaking of things that should be skipped: Wayward Children.

    I know better than to buy something just because I liked some of the creator’s other works. I know better. Worse, I even have a long history of bad experiences with young adult works by authors normally known for writing standard novels. And yet, I still bought the first four of these books and forced myself through them. There are so many negative things I could list about them, ranging from their physical length to their themes to their structure, but ultimately it’s probably best to keep it as succinct as possible and just say “They are young adult novels through and through”.

    Related posts:

    1. WHEN SORROWS COME & That Time I Got Reincarnated as a SLIME #12 Seanan McGuire‘s fifteenth October Daye novel is completely centered on...
    2. The SAGA of TANYA THE EVIL #12 & The Hero Laughs While Walking the Path of Vengeance #6 While waiting for the twelfth Youjo Senki novel to get...
    3. Blood Heir & So I’m a Spider, So What? #12 I actually read Ilona Andrews‘ Blood Heir way back at...
    4. Recent Books Normally I do these three at a time… but, well…...
    5. ARIFURETA #13 & Arifureta After I-V The last of the main Arifureta novels starts out much...

    Powered by YARPP.


    This entry was posted in Book Related and tagged Fantasy Indexing Paranormal Romance Seanan McGuire Urban Fantasy Wayward Children Young Adult Novel
  • Sparrow Hill Road & Laughter at the Academy

    Posted on April 13, 2020 5:41 pm by Offkorn Comment

    The first of Seanan McGuire’s Ghost Roads novels is a collection of related stories/songs which were repurposed into four ‘books’. Book 1 is very good, the follow-up is not. Book 3 fluctuates a bit, while the conclusion is abrupt/lacking. It’s interesting… but ends up too uneven to really care about whatever the sequel might contain.

    Laughter at the Academy is somewhat similar in that it’s a collection of stories, but here they’re all quite independent and run the gamut from Wayward Children to Newsflesh. You can see shades of those series, October Daye, the above mentioned Ghost Roads, Indexing, The Deep, and even Middlegame in the large assortment of mostly chapter-sized tales arrayed here.

    Being anthology bait as many of them are, don’t expect a consistency of quality (’cause there isn’t any), but they succeed quite brilliantly in showcasing the range of topics/foci found in the author’s full-sized works. Interestingly, pretty much all of them are ‘dark’ in some manner and one of the stories (The Tolling of Pavlov’s Bells) may as well have been written specifically for the current viral crisis. My only complaint would be that the intermittent/inconsistent introductory trigger warnings lifted from the fanfic community are aggravating to read.

    Related posts:

    1. Recent Books Normally I do these three at a time… but, well…...
    2. ARE YOU EVEN HUMAN & FEEDBACK Natalie Maher‘s Are You Even Human is a difficult book...
    3. Primer for the Apocalypse & Awakening The first of Braided Sky‘s Primer for the Apocalypse books...
    4. Rise: A Newsflesh Collection This is a collection of short stories and novellas which...
    5. ARIFURETA #13 & Arifureta After I-V The last of the main Arifureta novels starts out much...

    Powered by YARPP.


    This entry was posted in Book Related and tagged Fantasy Ghost Roads Paranormal Romance Science Fiction Seanan McGuire Urban Fantasy
  • The Unkindest Tide & Archangel’s War

    Posted on September 25, 2019 6:34 am by Offkorn Comment

    Seanan McQuire’s 13th October Daye novel is meant to conclude one of the series’ long-running plotlines. Instead it comes across more like an intermission. A rather arbitrary one. It does in fact eventually resolve what it set out to, yet the path traveled to get there is just so… random. Meanwhile, the Raj-centric story tacked onto the end is just plain bad.

    Archangel’s War is also meant to be a conclusion, this one to Nalini Singh’s Guild Hunter series (or perhaps just the Cascade-related central plot), and in contrast does the job with full marks. After the way the previous book ended on a cliffhanger I didn’t really know what to expect here and ended up pleasantly surprised by a smooth continuation that manages to wrap up just about every loose end to the point I’d be perfectly content with this as the last book in the series.

    Related posts:

    1. The Witch With No Name, The Great Ordeal, & The Unholy Consult The concluding novel in Kim Harrison‘s Hollows series makes it...
    2. WHEN SORROWS COME & That Time I Got Reincarnated as a SLIME #12 Seanan McGuire‘s fifteenth October Daye novel is completely centered on...
    3. Recent Books Normally I do these three at a time… but, well…...
    4. BE the SERPENT & Ruby Fever After the previous October Daye entry, things were looking up...
    5. Books; Before and After First the before, which was three books read back in...

    Powered by YARPP.


    This entry was posted in Book Related and tagged Guild Hunter Nalini Singh October Daye Paranormal Romance Seanan McGuire Urban Fantasy
  • Middlegame, Siren’s Song, & Honors

    Posted on June 20, 2019 2:28 pm by Offkorn Comment

    Seanan McGuire‘s Middlegame is a standalone story with no relation to any of her various series. It’s pretty remarkable for framing thematically dark fairy tale prose with time resets more commonly at home in science fiction. I had been avoiding her Wayward Children books, but may have to check them out after all just to see if they happen to resemble this in any way.

    Kristin McTiernan’s Black Magic’s Prey is a very… raw story. It starts out well enough, only to very quickly escalate into magical mind rape, lots of crying, sudden lesbianism, casual racism, razorblade gargling, situational rape, satan worship, and small town vindictiveness. And that’s all just in the first half (a pretty impressive accomplishment considering the book’s only about half the standard length), which is where I had to stop; I’m not keen on continually victimized protagonists and the summary for the followup just raises all sorts of questions I think I’d be better off not knowing the answers to.

    The Honors series is a sci-fi work co-authored by Rachel Caine and Ann Aguirre which (at least initially) brings to mind Aguirre’s earlier Sirantha Jax series. So, it’s more than a little odd that the ‘about the authors’ section make it seem like everything was Caine’s idea while going well out of the way to pretend that series doesn’t exist. Oddity aside, while the first book is quite engaging the second has a completely different atmosphere to it with: A forced focus on social justice issues, a bit of character assassination where the protagonist is concerned, an overall devolvement into battle shounen tropes, and a cliffhanger ending.

    Related posts:

    1. Relatively Recent Books Been procrastinating with adding these because it’s a pain. May...
    2. Recent Books Normally I do these three at a time… but, well…...
    3. Sparrow Hill Road & Laughter at the Academy The first of Seanan McGuire’s Ghost Roads novels is a...
    4. Tempt the Stars, Omens, & Parasite The sixth book in Karen Chance‘s Cassandra Palmer series is...
    5. Books; Before and After First the before, which was three books read back in...

    Powered by YARPP.


    This entry was posted in Book Related and tagged Ann Aguirre Honors Kristin McTiernan Paranormal Romance Rachel Caine Romance Science Fiction Seanan McGuire Siren's Song Urban Fantasy Young Adult Novel

Posts pagination

1 2 Next

  • Tag Groups

    Genre

    Action Action RPG Adventure Battle Shounen Board Game Card Game Comedy Comic Relief Coming of Age Cyberpunk Dating Sim Drama Dramatic Support Dystopia Ecchi Educational Exploration Fantasy FPS Harem History Hobby Horror Idol Magical Girl MMORPG Music Mystery Paranormal Romance Parody Puzzle Game Roguelike Romance RPG School Life Science Fiction Simulation Slice of Life Sports Steampunk Strategy Tactical RPG Thriller Urban Fantasy Virtual World Western Workplace

    Meta

    Alternative Version Amazon Prime Anime Original Comic Adaptation Crunchyroll Daisuki Dropped Finished First Person Perspective Funimation Game Adaptation HiDive Hulu Incomplete Source Literary Adaptation Live Action Adaptation LN Adaptation Mixed Media Project Movie Netflix Novel Adaptation Novella OVA Partial Adaptation Series Short Anime Televised Third Person Perspective VN Adaptation Web Novel Young Adult Novel
  • Pages

    • Anime Overviews
      • Disliked Anime
      • Preferred Anime
      • Skipped Anime
      • Miku Hatsune Concerts
    • Final Fantasy XIV
      • FFXIV Combat Macros
    • Game Guides
    • Game Mods
      • Subtitle Mods
    • MP3 Player Playlist
    • MTGO Draft & Event Decks
    • VtM oWoD Vampiric NPC Listing
  • Categories

    • Anime Related
      • 1981 – Autumn
      • 1982 – Spring
      • 1982 – Winter
      • 1983 – Winter
      • 1984 – Spring
      • 1984 – Summer
      • 1985 – Autumn
      • 1985 – Summer
      • 1986 – Summer
      • 1987 – Autumn
      • 1987 – Spring
      • 1987 – Summer
      • 1987 – Winter
      • 1988 – Autumn
      • 1988 – Spring
      • 1988 – Summer
      • 1988 – Winter
      • 1989 – Autumn
      • 1989 – Spring
      • 1989 – Summer
      • 1990 – Autumn
      • 1990 – Spring
      • 1990 – Summer
      • 1990 – Winter
      • 1991 – Autumn
      • 1991 – Winter
      • 1992 – Autumn
      • 1992 – Spring
      • 1992 – Summer
      • 1992 – Winter
      • 1993 – Autumn
      • 1993 – Spring
      • 1993 – Summer
      • 1993 – Winter
      • 1994 – Autumn
      • 1994 – Spring
      • 1994 – Summer
      • 1994 – Winter
      • 1995 – Autumn
      • 1995 – Spring
      • 1995 – Summer
      • 1995 – Winter
      • 1996 – Autumn
      • 1996 – Spring
      • 1996 – Summer
      • 1996 – Winter
      • 1997 – Spring
      • 1997 – Summer
      • 1997 – Winter
      • 1998 – Autumn
      • 1998 – Winter
      • 1999 – Autumn
      • 1999 – Spring
      • 1999 – Summer
      • 1999 – Winter
      • 2000 – Spring
      • 2001 – Autumn
      • 2001 – Spring
      • 2001 – Summer
      • 2002 – Autumn
      • 2002 – Spring
      • 2002 – Summer
      • 2002 – Winter
      • 2003 – Autumn
      • 2003 – Spring
      • 2003 – Summer
      • 2003 – Winter
      • 2004 – Autumn
      • 2004 – Spring
      • 2004 – Summer
      • 2004 – Winter
      • 2005 – Autumn
      • 2005 – Spring
      • 2005 – Summer
      • 2005 – Winter
      • 2006 – Spring
      • 2006 – Winter
      • 2007 – Autumn
      • 2007 – Spring
      • 2007 – Summer
      • 2007 – Winter
      • 2008 – Autumn
      • 2008 – Spring
      • 2008 – Summer
      • 2008 – Winter
      • 2009 – Autumn
      • 2009 – Spring
      • 2009 – Summer
      • 2009 – Winter
      • 2010 – Autumn
      • 2010 – Spring
      • 2010 – Summer
      • 2010 – Winter
      • 2011 – Autumn
      • 2011 – Spring
      • 2011 – Summer
      • 2011 – Winter
      • 2012 – Autumn
      • 2012 – Spring
      • 2012 – Summer
      • 2012 – Winter
      • 2013 – Autumn
      • 2013 – Spring
      • 2013 – Summer
      • 2013 – Winter
      • 2014 – Autumn
      • 2014 – Spring
      • 2014 – Summer
      • 2014 – Winter
      • 2015 – Autumn
      • 2015 – Spring
      • 2015 – Summer
      • 2015 – Winter
      • 2016 – Autumn
      • 2016 – Spring
      • 2016 – Summer
      • 2016 – Winter
      • 2017 – Autumn
      • 2017 – Spring
      • 2017 – Summer
      • 2017 – Winter
      • 2018 – Autumn
      • 2018 – Spring
      • 2018 – Summer
      • 2018 – Winter
      • 2019 – Autumn
      • 2019 – Spring
      • 2019 – Summer
      • 2019 – Winter
      • 2020 – Autumn
      • 2020 – Spring
      • 2020 – Summer
      • 2020 – Winter
      • 2021 – Spring
      • 2021 – Summer
      • 2021 – Winter
      • 2023 – Winter
    • Book Related
    • Internet Related
    • Movie & TV Related
    • Music Related
    • Uncategorized
    • Video Game Related
      • DLC
      • Gamecube
      • GBA
      • Guides
      • Nintendo DS
      • Nintendo Switch
      • PC
        • Emulation
        • Modding
      • PS2
      • PS3
      • SNES
      • Wii
  • Archives

  • Meta

    • Register
    • Log in
    • Entries feed
    • Comments feed
    • WordPress.org

©2025 raindrops Entries RSS and Comments RSS Raindrops Theme